Monday, January 17, 2005

The wheels have fallen off the wagon, or have they?

George W Bush II has recently been quoted in the media that the US social security system is about collapse. According to the actuaries at the Social Security Administration, it isn't. From a European perspective, this is a classic example of the socio-cultural and political chasm that lies between the US and Europe. Our concepts of a secularist societies and social responsibilities are so different. You can see it in its original form here.

A Question of Numbers


By ROGER LOWENSTEIN


THE CONSERVATIVE NEW DEAL

In 1938, the Social Security Act was only three years old, but its future was already very much in doubt. Conservatives claimed it would bankrupt the nation, and independent critics argued that the way it was financed amounted to ''financial hocus-pocus,'' as one editorial in The New York Times put it. President Franklin D. Roosevelt defended the program, said by a cabinet member to be his favorite, with some of his trademark oratory. ''Because it has become increasingly difficult for individuals to build their own security,'' the president told a national radio audience, ''government must now step in and help them lay the foundation stones.''

Social Security did become the cornerstone -- not only the biggest government entitlement plan but also the most universal, the most popular and the most enduring. But the debate over Social Security never ended. Barry Goldwater wanted to repeal it; Milton Friedman wrote in 1962 that it was an unjustifiable incursion on personal liberty; and David Stockman, the budget director who personified Ronald Reagan's efforts to shrink the federal government, tried to take a hatchet to Social Security, which he called a ''monster.''

But in this 70-year struggle, no other conservative has ever come as close to transforming the program as George W. Bush. He is making Social Security reform, including a partial privatization, a centerpiece of his second term. If the most ardent ideologues have their way, such a reform would be a first step toward a wholly new approach to retirement security -- one that would set aside the notion of collective insurance and guaranteed minimums for that of personal investing and responsibility.

This could do more to reverse the New Deal, and even the Great Society, than Goldwater, Stockman and Reagan ever dreamed of. ''We call it a conservative New Deal,'' says Stephen Moore, author of ''Bullish on Bush: How George W. Bush's Ownership Society Will Make America Stronger.'' In Moore's words, it will be a fundamental shift ''from an entitlement society to an ownership society.'' The key to this transformation, according to a generation of conservative thinkers and crusaders, is reducing the size and changing the nature of Social Security, which now pays benefits of half a trillion a year, and which will only grow bigger as America grows older.

The campaign to privatize has not only been about ideology; it has also focused on Social Security's supposed insolvency. Moore's book calls Social Security a ''Titanic . . . headed toward the iceberg'' and a program ''on the verge of collapse.'' A stream of other conservatives have bombarded the public, over years and decades, with prophecies of trillion-dollar liabilities and with metaphors intended to frighten -- ''train wreck,'' ''bankruptcy,'' ''cancer'' and so forth. Recently, a White House political deputy wrote a strategy note in which he said that Social Security is ''on an unsustainable course. That reality needs to be seared into the public consciousness.''

The campaign is potentially self-fulfilling: persuade enough people that Social Security is going bankrupt, and it will lose public support. Then Congress will be forced to act. And thanks to such unceasing alarums, many, and perhaps most, people today think the program is in serious financial trouble.

But is it? After Bush's re-election, I carefully read the 225-page annual report of the Social Security trustees. I also talked to actuaries and economists, inside and outside the agency, who are expert in the peculiar science of long-term Social Security forecasting. The actuarial view is that the system is probably in need of a small adjustment of the sort that Congress has approved in the past. But there is a strong argument, which the agency acknowledges as a possibility, that the system is solvent as is.

Although prudence argues for making a fix sooner rather than later, the program is not in crisis, nor is its potential shortfall irresolvable. Ideology aside, the scale of the fixes would not require Social Security to abandon the role that was conceived for it in 1935, and that it still performs today -- as an insurance fail-safe for the aged and others and as a complement to people's private market savings.

PREDICTIONS AND BEST GUESSES

About 47 million people -- retirees and their dependents, under-age survivors of deceased workers and the disabled -- receive a check from Social Security every month. The money for this colossal endeavor comes from a payroll tax on current workers and on their employers. The program is a model of efficiency; expenses are low, as pension plans go, and participation is near universal. Benefits rise with the level of earnings, but they are tilted toward progressivity, so that those at the bottom get more in proportion to their earnings and those at the top get less. Social Security also delivers a considerable nonmonetary benefit: people who have contributed throughout their working lives know that, regardless of the ebb and flow of their careers and, indeed, of the stock market, a guaranteed pension awaits them.

Currently, Social Security is running a hefty surplus; the payroll tax brings in more dollars than what goes out in benefits. By law, Social Security invests that surplus in Treasury securities, which it deposits into a reserve known as a trust fund, which now holds more than one and a half trillion dollars. But by 2018, as baby boomers retire en masse, the system will go into deficit. At that point, in order to pay benefits, it will begin to draw on the assets in the trust fund.

The debate over Social Security's solvency is really two debates. The first is over how long the trust fund will last. The law requires the Social Security Administration to estimate its financial condition for 75 years into the future, and the agency's conclusions depend on the assumptions it makes about what America will look like decades hence -- how much people will earn, how large their families will be, how long they will live.

Politicians and other commentators tend to speak about these long-range trends, or at least about Social Security's finances, with an air of precision. This is almost amusing, since few economists can predict the swings in the federal budget even a year in advance. Joshua Bolten, head of Bush's Office of Management and Budget, said of Social Security last month, ''The one thing I can say for sure is that if left unattended, the system will be unable to make good on its promises.'' But the Social Security Administration itself pretends to no such certainty. Its actuaries (about 40 are on staff) frankly admit that the level of, say, immigration in 2020, or of wages in 2040, is impossible to forecast. ''The only thing we are sure of is that it won't happen precisely as we project,'' says Stephen Goss, the chief actuary at the agency. And the trustees' annual report, which is based on the actuaries' analysis, takes pains to say that it is not making a prediction. It makes a projection -- three different ones, actually -- that amount to informed but very rough guesses. The agency's best guess, labeled its ''intermediate'' case, is that the system will exhaust its reserves in 2042. At that point, as payroll taxes continue to roll in, it would be able to pay just over 70 percent of scheduled benefits. That would leave a substantial deficit, but one that Congress could easily avert if it were to act now when the projected problem is more than a generation away.

What's more, there is a strong case to be made that the agency is erring on the side of being overly pessimistic. If its more optimistic projection turns out to be correct, then there will be no need for any benefit cuts or payroll-tax increases over the full 75 years.

No one can definitively predict that outcome, either, of course, but David Langer, an independent actuary who made a study of Social Security's previous projections compared with the actual results in 2003, thinks the ''optimistic'' case is its most accurate. Over a recent 10-year span, the trustees' intermediate guesses turned out to be quite pessimistic. Its optimistic guesses were dead on, and its pessimistic case -- sort of a doomsday situation -- was wildly inaccurate.

And, contrary to widespread belief, recent demographic trends have been modestly better (from an actuary's gloomy standpoint) than anticipated. For instance, longevity hasn't increased as much as expected. Partly as a result, since 1997 the agency has pushed back, by 13 years, the date at which it projects its reserves will be exhausted. In other words, as the cries of impending doom started to crescendo, the guardians of the system have grown more optimistic.

IS THE TRUST FUND TRUSTWORTHY?

The second debate concerning solvency is over whether the securities in the trust fund will be honored or whether, in Moore's pointed imagery, the fund will resemble a bank ''after it's been robbed by Bonnie and Clyde.'' This seems an odd preoccupation. Social Security does not own junk bonds or third-world debt; it invests in U.S. Treasuries, considered the safest investment on the planet. Since 1970 there have been 11 years in which Social Security has operated at a deficit; each time, it redeemed bonds from the trust fund without a fuss. Goss, the agency's actuary, says he has no doubt it will be able to do so again. ''Absolutely,'' he said when asked if the trust-fund bonds are sound.

This isn't what some conservatives have said. Paul O'Neill, the former treasury secretary, went so far as to say that Social Security has no assets. In anti-Social Security literature, the ''no assets'' contention isn't even debated; it's treated as gospel. According to Michael Tanner, head of the Cato Institute Project on Social Security Choice, the agency's pauperism has turned America's seniors into ''supplicants'': after working and paying taxes their entire lives, ''they earn the privilege of going hat in hand to the government and hoping that politicians decide to give them some money for retirement.'' The implication is that the money isn't there: graybeards will have to beg for it.

Cato, a libertarian policy center founded in the late 1970's, has been arguing for 25 years that Social Security is on the verge of crisis. In a recent position paper, Tanner wrote that Social Security faces a horrendous unfinanced liability of $26 trillion over 75 years. In a footnote, he cited the 2003 trustees' annual report. Actually, the trustees' intermediate projection is for a deficit, over 75 years, of $3.7 trillion. Though that is a lot of money, it could be covered by an immediate surcharge to the payroll tax of less than two percentage points, or by various combinations of tax hikes and benefit cuts, each of them quite manageable. But $26 trillion is too big a hole to fix. When I asked Tanner about the footnote, he admitted that the trustees didn't actually say $26 trillion; Tanner derived the figure by counting the cash-flow deficits that the trustees project from 2019 on out. In other words, he ignores the next 15 years or so, during which time Social Security will be running a surplus. And he assumes that the assets in the trust fund, which should be accruing interest into the 2040's, won't exist, either. Tanner counts only the bad years and only the bad numbers. Another doomsayer, former Republican Representative John Kasich, pegged the Social Security deficit at $120 trillion in a recent op-ed -- some 32 times the agency's figure. (Kasich toted up annual deficits in nominal -- not inflation-adjusted -- dollars for every year through 2080, by which time a hamburger could cost $40.)

Such hyperbolic claims aside, there is a serious issue at the heart of what worries critics. It isn't that the trust fund is broken; it's that the existence of the fund is seducing the government to spend more than it otherwise would, thus brooking larger deficits in the future. Since Social Security lends its surplus to the Treasury (that's what it means to be investing in Treasuries), it is parking its surplus cash with the government. And just as lending money to a child outside a candy store may impose an impossible temptation, so the government may feel tempted while it holds onto Social Security's purse.

Ideally, Congress would recognize that the surplus is only temporary and would, therefore, take pains that the money lent to it is properly saved -- that is, that it run a surplus. But the government is operating at a deficit. So you must conclude that rather than saving Social Security's surplus, the government has been spending it -- on the military, education, tax cuts. In only 15 years, the government will have to start repaying its debt to Social Security. It will be able to do so. If need be, it will borrow, as it has borrowed for many purposes since 1776. The amount of borrowing, which could very gradually scale up to 1 or 2 percent of the country's gross domestic product, will be far smaller than the present federal deficit, which is just under 4 percent of G.D.P. But to avoid layering one deficit atop another, the government needs to exercise discipline -- to not overindulge in candy -- in the years when Social Security is running a surplus.

DEMAGOGUES, DOCTORS AND DEFICITS

The fear that the trust fund would represent a ''perpetual invitation'' to Congress has bedeviled Social Security since its inception. Economists of the 1930's knew that every pension plan starts with more workers contributing into the system than there are retirees. But down the road, as those workers retire, obligations mount. Therefore, they recognized, any system that builds an adequate reserve for the future must collect more than it needs in the early years. And though social scientists of the 30's could not anticipate the war or the baby boom that would follow it, they knew that America's population was going to age.

In 1934, when Franklin Roosevelt formed the Committee on Economic Security to design what was in effect the first federal safety net, the committee hired three actuaries to stargaze into the future. The actuaries predicted that the proportion of Americans over 65 -- then only 5.4 percent -- would rise to 12.65 percent in 1990, meaning that retiree costs would soar. They were just a tad high; the actual figure would be 12.49 percent.

The committee was sharply divided on how to prepare for this demographic onslaught. Harry Hopkins, who oversaw the New Deal's relief program, thought the U.S. should simply pay retirement benefits from general funds; the more fiscally minded Henry Morgenthau Jr., the treasury secretary, wanted a self-financed system. F.D.R. sided with Morgenthau; above all, he said the system should be simple -''nothing elaborate or alarming about it.''

But alarm was very much the order of the day. When Roosevelt was swept into office in 1933, he had been preoccupied with the emergency of the Depression -- 10 million unemployed, 18 million on relief, the country's business output cut by a quarter and its morale shattered. He responded with a whirlwind of legislation and with rhetoric that, for a while, truly inspired. By 1934, the energy of the New Deal's first days had begun to subside, and yet the Depression had not abated. Meanwhile, the administration was being outflanked by political zealots, utopians and snake-oil salesmen, who increasingly appealed to desperate Americans. In California, the novelist Upton Sinclair was running for governor on a radical platform to ''end poverty.'' In Louisiana, Huey Long was leveraging his ''share the wealth'' movement into a national campaign. The Rev. Charles Coughlin, a demagogic and incendiary radio orator, was attracting millions of listeners with his attacks on bankers, Bolsheviks and assorted other villains.

By far the oddest of these ducks was an elderly doctor in Long Beach, Calif., Francis Townsend, who had lost his county medical job to the Depression. Dr. Townsend, a onetime ranch hand and mining speculator, wrote to the local newspaper suggesting a fantastic retirement scheme: the government should distribute $200 a month to each American over 60 and pay for it with a sales tax. When recycled through the economy, he augured, these lavish pensions would ''abolish unemployment'' forever. His proposed stipend was well above the average American's monthly wage, and his plan was demonstrably unworkable. But in rural America, it had the lure of an elixir. ''Townsend Clubs'' popped up across the country. Millions of members were recruited, a weekly newspaper was printed and dozens of U.S. representatives dutifully lined up in support.

''The Congress can't stand the pressure of the Townsend Plan unless we have a real old-age insurance system, nor can I face the country without'' one, Roosevelt told his labor secretary, Frances Perkins. Each had been thinking of social insurance since well before the emergence of Townsend -- as governor of New York, Roosevelt dispatched Perkins to England to study the British state insurance system. But characteristically, F.D.R. had let the idea simmer until the moment was ripe. The domestic agitation was his opportunity.

In January 1935, the Economic Security committee delivered a sweeping proposal for ''cradle to grave'' insurance. Much of the bill merely authorized the federal government to distribute aid to the states, but two aspects of it were revolutionary: a plan for unemployment insurance and one for retirement. F.D.R., however, was greatly troubled by a detail in the latter. Though the payroll tax was scheduled to rise, in staircase fashion, within two generations it would be insufficient to cover benefits. Perkins explained that as the number of retirees rose, funds from the Treasury would have to cover the shortfall.

''Ah, but this is the same old dole under another name,'' F.D.R. said. F.D.R. had hoped that handouts would no longer be necessary as the economy recovered, and he shrewdly anticipated that in future generations, welfare-type programs would be vulnerable to political attack. He wanted Social Security to be different -- universal and enduring. Therefore, he insisted, it had to be self-supporting. Thus was conceived the (soon-controversial) trust fund. To build a future reserve, the New Dealers doubled the initial level of the payroll tax to 2 percent, applied up to a cap that was initially set at $3,000 of income. This added a regressive aspect to the plan, shielding the highest income brackets. Nonetheless, in August 1935, legislation was enacted that, in F.D.R.'s words, would ''give some measure of protection to the average citizen.''

The public strongly supported the new program, but conservatives attacked it as a socialistic scourge. Playing on the fact that each worker was to receive a government number, the Hearst papers published front-page illustrations of a man wearing a chain with a dog tag. Henry Ford said Social Security could cost Americans their basic freedoms, like the right to change jobs or to move from one town to another. A shareholder in a utility filed suit, claiming that the payroll tax was unconstitutional. The case went to the Supreme Court, where, in 1937, Justice Benjamin Cardozo, as if to resolve the historic debate over federalism, ruled, ''The conception of the spending power advocated by Hamilton . . . has prevailed over that of Madison.'' The new agency's organizational elan won over some critics. W. Albert Linton, a skeptical insurance executive, visited the Social Security headquarters in Baltimore and was amazed when the staff plucked his name and address from among the 26 million records. ''I think it is amazing,'' he said, ''the way they have solved the technical aspect.''

But the opposition wouldn't die. The issue that sparked the loudest protest was one that still burns today: the trust fund. Deductions from pay envelopes began in 1937, but benefits weren't scheduled to start until 1942, and there was a great deal of mistrust about where the money was going. Government actuaries sheepishly explained that Social Security was building a reserve eventually expected to reach $47 billion. This was an awesome sum -- eight times the total then in circulation. Alfred Landon, the Republican who ran against Roosevelt in 1936, called it ''a cruel hoax'' on the American people. His platform, sounding uncannily that like that of Republicans today, stated, ''The so-called reserve fund . . . is no reserve at all, because the fund will contain nothing but the government's promise to pay.'' Arthur Altmeyer, head of the Social Security board, came under heavy fire at a Congressional hearing. Looking for a way to safeguard the reserve, he made an intriguing suggestion: why not let the government invest in sound private securities, and thus insulate the surplus from Congress's eager hands? As Altmeyer recounted in his memoir, Arthur Vandenberg, a Republican senator from Michigan, threw up his hands and snickered, ''That would be socialism!''

To quell the furor, Roosevelt turned to that standby device for embattled politicians -- an advisory council. The council arrived at an expedient solution, though one with troubling longer-term implications. It suggested increasing benefits for the first generation of retirees, even though that group had paid little in payroll taxes. An amendment in 1939 raised their benefits and also created new classes of beneficiaries -- wives, widows and survivors. This was a departure from the principle that all workers would be treated equally (couples would get more than single workers) and added an element of ''need'' -- a point that would rankle conservatives and later fuel the privatization movement. But in the political climate of 1939, it had the advantage of soaking up surplus taxes and greatly reducing the rate at which reserves would accumulate in the trust fund. F.D.R., anxious to have the controversy settled, went along, even though the changes paved the way for the eventual deficits he had feared.

THE FIRST (AND ONLY) CRISIS

The crunch came, as actuaries had predicted, in the late 1970's. Part of the problem they had not foreseen; Social Security benefits were skyrocketing because of inflation. In the 70's, Congress decided to index retirees' benefits to the cost of living. The timing was awful. Not only did inflation soar, but incomes -- the basis of payroll contributions -- stagnated. Critics like those at the newly formed Cato Institute warned of disaster. A former Nixon cabinet member, Peter Peterson, began to attract attention by arguing that any pay-as-you-go system (in which one generation supports another, as today) was inherently unstable, and advocated deep cuts in the rate at which benefits increased. The criticism had an ideological as well as an economic edge. In a pre-financed system -- in which, for instance, each worker invests for his own later retirement -- society never faces a liability. But individuals may come up short (if their investments fare badly) and live out poorer retirements. President Carter, responding to the darkening outlook, became, in 1977, the first president to legislate a belt-tightening.

Carter's efforts, however, didn't suffice. The trouble was that Social Security's actuaries had been way too optimistic. The actuaries had assumed that from 1978 to 1982 inflation would total 28 percent; the actual figure would be 60 percent. And they had predicted that wages would grow by 13 percent after inflation, whereas, in fact, real wages didn't rise at all; they declined. Social Security's experts were hardly the only people surprised by the dreadful economy, which was buffeted by skyrocketing oil prices, Middle East turmoil and a slumping stock market. Regardless, in 1981, Social Security experts announced that the trust fund would run dry in a year or two. That left the problem up to a new president, Ronald Reagan.

As a candidate for president, Reagan had proclaimed that he was ''pledged to a Social Security program that will reassure these senior citizens of ours they're going to continue to get their money.'' By then, Social Security had become a program that politicians couldn't afford to oppose and, indeed, that most Americans supported. President Eisenhower, a Republican, had proved this in 1956 when -- to the great disappointment of conservatives -- he supported a significant expansion of Social Security to include the disabled. But among adamant free marketers, the dream of upending Social Security lived on. One of the more prominent postwar opponents, in fact, was Reagan, a disarming actor then transitioning to political life.

Reagan began speaking out against Social Security in the late 50's. At the time, Democrats were trying to extend Social Security to health care -- to what would eventually become Medicare -- and Reagan worked with the American Medical Association to try to stop them. The A.M.A. conducted a stealth campaign (unearthed in 1999 by the political scientist Max Skidmore) known as Operation Coffee Cup, in which doctors' wives would urge women in their communities to oppose the plan in letters to Congress. Reagan produced a record album for that campaign in which he criticized Social Security for ''supplanting'' private savings and warned that subsidized medicine would curtail Americans' freedom. Warm and folksy even as he envisioned a bleak Orwellian future, Reagan said that Big Brother could start with health care, ''and pretty soon your son won't decide when he's in school, where he will go or what he will do for a living. He will wait for the government to tell him.''

Reagan gave slightly altered versions of this speech in personal appearances around the country, attacking Social Security as a ''sure loser'' of a program, and one that would worsen, not alleviate, the hazards of age. In the 70's, Reagan continued to sermonize against Social Security, often suggesting that it be made voluntary or more voluntary. At first blush, this sounded reasonable. As most people don't save enough for their retirement, however, under a voluntary system many who opted out would wind up destitute. Higher-earning workers (who get a lower proportional return on their payroll taxes) would opt out for certain. This problem is known as adverse selection. Wealthier people contributing higher taxes exit the system, leaving less revenue and a higher burden for the poorer people who remain. In effect, it would become an unpopular welfare program.

Once Reagan was in the Oval Office, he allowed his budget director, David Stockman, to handle the crisis. Stockman, who was waging a war on government spending, tried to exploit the moment to curtail Social Security sharply. It was Stockman's idea to cut benefits to early retirees by one-third. Without those cuts, he warned, the U.S. could suffer ''the most devastating bankruptcy in history.'' There were two weaknesses in the Stockman approach. First, he exaggerated. The deficit looming in 1983 was only temporary. (Since the birthrate dropped during the Depression, the number of seniors coming of age in the 1990's would decline, providing the agency with a respite.) Second, Stockman was politically naive. By proposing cuts for people on the verge of retirement, he triggered vehement protests. Members of the Republican-controlled Senate showed their instinct for self-preservation by voting 96-0 for a resolution intended to distance themselves from Stockman. James Baker, Reagan's chief of staff, urged the White House to do likewise. So Reagan, like F.D.R., bounced the problem to a commission, this time led by a well-known economic consultant, Alan Greenspan.

The 15-member commission got nowhere until December 1982. Then, with default only months away, an unofficial subgroup began to meet in secret. Robert Ball, a former Social Security commissioner, and Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan negotiated for the Democrats opposite Baker for the White House.

In the end, they compromised on a combination of benefit cuts and tax hikes. The payroll tax, then 10.16 percent, was already scheduled to rise, but the negotiators sped up the implementation of the increase. (Today the rate is 12.4 percent.) Moreover, Congress agreed to hike the retirement age from 65 to 67. This change, which is being phased in very slowly (the retirement age is now 65 and 6 months) had the same effect as cutting benefits. Greenspan and company now calculated that Social Security would build a giant reserve, sufficient to see it through the middle decades of the 21st century. This was the original F.D.R. approach -- build a trust fund. President Reagan said the package ''assures the elderly that America will always keep the promises made in troubled times a half-century ago.''

Social Security's next few annual reports made best-guess (intermediate) projections of solvency for 75 years, meaning it expected the system to remain solvent until 2060 and beyond. So the question that should arise now, but that has been oddly ignored is, What happened?

ARE ACTUARIES tOO GLOOMY?

Nothing did. Or in the words of Robert Ball, the nonagenarian former commissioner, ''nothing in the real world.'' But perceptions changed, and the balance of opinion began to shift in favor of reform. To some extent, that shift was bipartisan. In the mid-1980's and early 90's, Democrats discovered they didn't love deficits after all. When it began to appear that Congress was incapable of keeping its hands off Social Security's surplus, fiscally prudent Democrats like Moynihan and Bob Kerrey came out in favor of individual accounts. President Clinton famously campaigned to ''save Social Security first'' -- meaning that Congress should balance the budget. Meanwhile, the popular impression that any fool could make money in the stock market (for a while, any fool did) made private accounts seem like a natural. In the 1996 campaign, even among Republican contenders, only Steve Forbes favored privatization; by 2000 it was party doctrine.

Social Security's actuaries also began to make more pessimistic assumptions about the future. To quote the report of yet another Social Security advisory panel, this one from the mid 90's, ''It is pointed out that while today there are 3.3 workers paying into the system for every beneficiary drawing benefits, over time this ratio will change to two workers per beneficiary. . . . However, this has almost nothing to do with why there is a . . . deficit.'' The report continued, ''The ratio was fully taken into account in the 1983 financing provisions.'' So why did Social Security begin to forecast a more rapid exhaustion of the trust fund? Social Security was burned in the 70's and early 80's by being too optimistic. Now the actuaries are leaning the other way. ''It's a less optimistic estimate today,'' says Harry Ballantyne, who was chief actuary until 2001.

Social Security's key long-range projection is that, over 75 years, it will come up short by an average of 1.89 percent of payroll. Though deficits would still loom beyond 2080, the problem could be fixed until then by an immediate tax increase of 1.89 percent, or a benefit cut of roughly 13 percent. (Democrats tend to favor a combination.) But this all assumes that the middle projection is right. And several underlying assumptions of that middle projection tend to exaggerate the potential deficit. The first concerns longevity. A 65-year-old man today can expect to live to nearly 82. According to the most likely projection, in 2080 he should expect to live to 86. Goss says that the agency is assuming that medical technology will deliver more ''miracles.'' Most demographers agree with him, and some even think the agency is not being optimistic enough. The only trouble is, as Goss notes, that over the past 20 years ''they have been wrong at every turn. There has been less improvement than we were expecting.'' Indeed, the improvement in mortality has slowed significantly. And no one is sure why it has slowed. Nonetheless, the agency expects a sharp rebound over ensuing decades. Its fiscal gloominess thus depends on a speculative uptick in medical miracles.

Immigration is another contentious point. Immigration is good for the system because immigrants are earners and taxpayers. Though immigration has been rising, Social Security projects that it will taper off sharply, from 1.2 million a year to 900,000 in 20 years. This forecast is curious, because if the birthrate in America declines as anticipated, the country will need more foreign workers.

Rising wages are also a boon to Social Security's finances. Forecasting wages is difficult, as the trustees' report frankly admits, but it seems undeniable that as society ages, businesses will be harder pressed to find workers, and that should push wages higher. The trustees, however, project that real wages will grow at only 1.1 percent a year -- roughly equal to the level of the last 40 years.

The basic point here is that tiny swings in any of these or other factors could improve -- or worsen -- the program's balances. If a few of them lean in the direction of the optimistic forecast, the trust fund will cover benefits through 2080, or close to it. Would such a program, which appears to be solvent or near solvent until the limit of what is humanly forecastable, be improved upon by the various schemes for privatization?

PRIVATE ACCOUNTS DON'T SAVE MONEY

Social Security does not provide, and was not meant to provide, a satisfactory retirement on its own. The average stipend for a 65-year-old retiring today is $1,184 a month, or about $14,000 a year. About half of Americans also have private pension plans, but for two-thirds of the elderly, Social Security supplies the majority of day-to-day income. For the poorest 20 percent, about seven million, Social Security is all they have. Even those figures understate the program's importance. According to an agency publication, ''Income of the Population 55 or Older: 2000,'' 8 percent of elderly beneficiaries were poor, but a startling 48 percent would have been below the poverty line had they not been receiving Social Security. Charles Blahous, the White House point man on Social Security, publicly criticized this calculation as ''mindless,'' and the Social Security agency no longer computes the figure.

Conservative economists say the figure is irrelevant: if Social Security didn't exist, people would save more. This may be true of economists, but what about the rest of us? The argument illustrates the ideological agenda of those who favor privatization: they want to change people's behavior. But how will the proposals to privatize, several of which are before Congress, actually work? Basically, younger workers would be allowed to divert a portion of their payroll taxes into individual accounts. Upon retirement, these workers would get lower Social Security benefits supplemented by whatever had accumulated in their portfolios.

But since the diverted money would not be available to pay benefits to current retirees, the government would have to undertake significant borrowing to pay people now in their middle and older decades. Eventually, the system might transition to one in which most people mostly relied on their personal accounts. But this transition would take many decades.

The president is expected to back a plan similar to one recommended by the advisory council he appointed, in 2001. That plan opts for a slow transition, keeping entitlement-type minimums in place. The amount of money to be diverted into personal accounts -- and therefore, the potential gains -- is relatively small. Some free-market purists are unhappy about this. But Bush's economists, whatever else is said of them, are determined not to re-enact the Stockman debacle by moving too quickly and enacting immediate cuts. They have read their history.

The White House asked the Congressional Budget Office to analyze one advisory council plan. That plan would allow workers born after a certain date (perhaps 1950) to siphon about a third of the payroll tax into individual accounts, up to $1,000 a year. The money could be invested in any of three choices (other plans provide for wider menus) and would be converted into an annuity upon retirement.

The C.B.O. assumes that the typical worker would invest half of his allocation in stocks and the rest in bonds. The C.B.O. projects the average return, after inflation and expenses, at 4.9 percent. This compares with the 6 percent rate (about 3.5 percent after inflation) that the trust fund is earning now.

Proponents hail the plan for forcing savings on the government. But the diversion of money into individual accounts would save the government nothing, since it would have to borrow to offset the loss of the diverted dollars. The individual accounts represent a transfer, not a savings.

The second feature of the plan would link future benefit increases to inflation rather than to wages. Because wages typically grow faster, this would mean a rather substantial benefit cut. That cut would mean a savings for the government. This is a political choice; we can always save money by reducing benefits. But it's important to stress that the savings result from cuts, not from the decision to privatize.

Overall, the plan is gentler toward lower-income seniors than wealthier ones, but all seniors would be poorer than under present law. In other words, absent a sustained roaring bull market, the private accounts would not fully make up for the benefit cuts. According to the C.B.O.'s analysis, which, like all projections of this sort should be regarded as a best guess, a low-income retiree in 2035 would receive annual benefits (including the annuity from his private account) of $9,100, down from the $9,500 forecast under the present program. A median retiree would be cut severely, from $17,700 to $13,600. On the plus side, budget deficits would be lower in the future. But, because of the lengthy transition, that ''future'' is exceedingly remote -some 50 years down the road. In the interim, deficits would rise by up to 1.5 percent of the country's G.D.P.

ONE WAY TO USE THE MARKET

One rationale for privatization is that workers would get a better return on their money in Wall Street securities than with Social Security's dowdy old Treasuries. This notion, which has Wall Street investment banks salivating, was especially in vogue during the 90's, when the stock market was soaring. When the bubble burst, advocates reined in their sales pitch, but they still are unrealistically sanguine. Last year, Tanner of the Cato Institute wrote that ''over the worst 20-year period of market performance in U.S. history . . . the stock market produced a positive real return of more than 3 percent.'' Actually, the market has done worse than 3 percent per annum in nine different 20-year periods.

In any case, Social Security could capture the return on stocks, without putting individuals at risk, by investing in equities directly. This would also achieve another frequently stated objective: keeping the government's hands off the Social Security trust fund. That option would be far more efficient, in economic terms, than separating the money into 150 million disparate accounts. Costs are much lower for one big investor. And more important, in a system of individual accounts, benefits will vary with individual choices, and some people will make poor ones. In Sweden, where the retirement system has included private accounts since 2000, the majority of Swedes made excessively risky investment choices by putting money into stocks at the market top, according to Richard Thaler, a University of Chicago behavioral economist. Finally, pooling the investment pools the risk, and thus reduces the danger of retiring at the wrong time. In a system of personal accounts, someone who retired after a market crash would be out of luck.

So it is notable that all the current proposals to privatize involve the economically inferior option of individual accounts. But privatization advocates aren't motivated solely, and perhaps not even primarily, by economics. Glenn Hubbard, Bush's former top economic adviser, wrote in Newsweek that an ''obvious objective'' of privatization is ''to advance the president's ownership society agenda.'' Such pro-free-market sentiment has a long lineage. Remember Senator Vandenberg, who fretted in the 30's that public ownership of private securities would amount to socialism? Even though state pension funds and some U.S. agencies, including the Federal Reserve, put some pension money in stock-index funds, conservatives still react as if such a solution for Social Security were akin to turning it over to the Kremlin. Peter Ferrara, a former White House staff member under Reagan and now senior fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation, who has been proposing Social Security privatization plans since the late 1970's, told me that economics ''was not my primary motivation. It was ideological. We don't want the government controlling that much investment.''

HOW BUSH WOULD CUT BENEFITS

There is a policy choice that unites Social Security's critics -- from Goldwater to Reagan to Bush -- which is that the program should be balanced by shaving benefits rather than by raising taxes. They favor smaller government, so shrinking Social Security (rather than increasing its financing) serves their broader aim. Indeed, though the public continues to oppose cutting benefits, Bush has ruled out any solution that involves a tax hike.

Reagan said the program had morphed from the humble insurance plan formulated by F.D.R. (for whom he voted four times) into a swollen caricature of government excess. The first Social Security recipient, a legal secretary in Vermont named Ida Fuller, started with a benefit of $22.54 a month. Today's retirees obviously do better (even after adjusting for inflation). Nonetheless, according to Lawrence Thompson, who was the Social Security acting commissioner in the 90's, the retiree program is not really more ''generous'' now than it was in the past. Like other pension systems, Social Security was designed to replace a fixed portion of a retiree's previous earnings. For a single person with average earnings, initial benefits were intended to replace about 40 percent of income. They are still pegged to 40 percent of income.

Since wages generally rise faster than inflation, retirees in each generation get more in real dollars than those in previous ones. Contemporary critics, like Kasich and the Bush council, would slow the rate of future increases by linking benefits only to inflation. Though this would save a lot of money, its effect on retirees should be understood.

Seniors now get an initial benefit that is tied to a fixed portion of their pre-retirement wages. If the index was changed, their pensions would be pegged to a fixed portion of a previous generation's income. If this standard had been in force since the beginning, retirees today would be living like those in the 1940's -- like Ida Fuller, which would mean $300 a month in today's dollars, as opposed to roughly $1,200 a month.

One way or another, societies with more old people have to devote more resources to them. Right now, benefits amount to 4.3 percent of G.D.P. The trustees' most likely projection assumes that over the next 75 years that figure will rise to 6.6 percent. In the more optimistic case, benefits will rise to 5.2 percent. Given the substantial increase in the elderly population, neither of these figures seems rash or out of proportion. The increased cost would be on a par with that of making Bush's first-term tax cuts permanent, which is projected to be about 2 percent of G.D.P.

And though future generations of workers will have to support more retirees, they will also be having fewer children. In fact, according to the Social Security actuaries, the total ''dependency'' burden (that is, the number of nonworking seniors and kids that each working-age adult will have to support) will remain lower than at its baby-boom peak. ''In a grand social sense,'' says Thompson, the former Social Security commissioner, ''we can support more seniors where there are fewer people in day care.''

THE INESCAPABLE COSTS OF AGING

Ultimately, every 75-year forecast is just a guess, and therefore every approach must accommodate a range of possible outcomes. Plans that link worker benefits to the stock market automatically adjust -- if the economy underperforms, then workers get lower benefits. This enhances, rather than mitigates, whatever is the trend in people's private savings. As Thompson says, ''The default adjustment is you eat less.'' This could be brutal and also unfair, especially to the post-1983 generation of workers that, on the say-so of Greenspan and Reagan that the trust fund would be honored, has paid a sacrifice in both reduced benefits and higher taxes.

What other solution is there? Ball, who joined the system in 1939 as a $1,620-a-year district officer in Newark, has thought of one. He starts from two premises: it would be reckless not to make some adjustments now, but foolish to make too much of 75-year prophecies. ''In 1928, there was no way to forecast the Depression, World War II, the birth-control pill. We have to stop acting as if 75-year estimates were absolute,'' he told me.

Nonetheless, Ball would tweak the system in several modest ways to reduce the projected deficit. For instance, he would very gradually raise the cap on income subject to the payroll tax, now at $90,000. This would reverse a recent regressive trend. Income distribution in America has become more skewed, thus upper-income folks have earned more money that has escaped the tax. Ball would also add three other, smaller fixes to further tighten benefits and raise taxes. (There are many variations of these fixes floating around the Beltway.) After Ball's prescription, how much of a deficit would then remain? Possibly a fraction of a percent of the payroll, possibly zero. The answer would depend on the net effects of future birth rates, wars, diseases, inventions and so forth. Enter now Ball's little accommodation to uncertainty. It is that Congress simply resolve now to impose, 50 years hence, a payroll tax increase sufficient to close whatever gap exists over the ensuing quarter-century. This could not be enforced now, of course, but that is Ball's point. He wants to free the Congress, and the rest of us, from the annual game of insisting on an exact and illusory far-off balance; to diminish the perception that we must urgently adjust to economic and demographic developments too distant to be forecast.

The 2004 ''Economic Report of the President'' takes dead aim at such an approach. It reckons that all pay-as-you-go systems will eventually be doomed by demographics, and that solutions like Ball's will only push back the date that the trust fund runs out of money by a few years. The White House worries that any fix that covers 75 years of benefits could still bequeath a deficit in the 76th year. ''The nation must act to avert a long-foreseen future crisis in the financing of its old-age entitlement programs,'' the report states. Its assumptions may be true, or they may not be, but the conclusion suggests a misplaced allegiance: We have an obligation to the distant future, but don't we owe a greater debt to the current generation and to those that immediately follow?

Prudence dictates taking steps now to minimize the possible shortfall. This could include raising the cap, some modest cuts and tax increases and a gradual redeployment of the trust fund into assets that may not be tapped, willy-nilly, for whatever legislative purpose. But only a real crisis would dictate undoing an institution that has provided a safety net for retirees, that has helped to preserve in the social fabric some minimum of shared responsibility and that has been supported by workers in good faith. And, in looking at Social Security today, the crisis is yet to be found.


Roger Lowenstein is a contributing writer and the author of ''Origins of the Crash.'' His last article for the magazine was about presidents and job creation.

Sunday, January 16, 2005

The Watchmen Personality Inventory

The Watchmen Personality Inventory

You can find out which superhero's personality from The Watchmen comic series do you correspond to here, mine came in as The Comedian (pictured above), which I guess makes me a bit of a mercenary and cynical to boot. The Watchmen held a mirror up to society at the end of the 1980's and has become strangely relevant today. I came across the series, after a friend pointed out where the blood stained smiley on the front of the picture sleeve of Bomb the Bass' Beat Dis came from. The smiley then exploded on to the acid house scene, the irony between what the logo meant in the book and the warehouse was not lost on me.

Going off big time

Campaigning journalist blasts CBS management for burning their journalists following their highlight of George Bush's extraordinary military service record. Palast's email is below:

From: palast at gregpalast.com
Subject: CBS' COWARDICE AND CONFLICTS BEHIND PURGE
Date: 11 January 2005 22:59:10 GMT
To: gedcarroll at mac.com

CBS' COWARDICE AND CONFLICTS BEHIND PURGE

Network's Craven Back-Down on Bush Draft Dodge Report Sure to Get a Standing Rove-ation at White House
Tuesday, January 11, 2005
By Greg Palast

"Independent" my ass. CBS' cowardly purge of five journalists who exposed George Bush's dodging of the Vietnam War draft was done under cover of what the network laughably called an "Independent Review Panel."

The "panel" was just two guys as qualified for the job as they are for landing the space shuttle: Dick Thornburgh and Louis Boccardi.

Remember Dickie Thornburgh? He was on the Bush 41 Administration's payroll. His grand accomplishment as Bush's Attorney General was to whitewash the investigation of the Exxon Valdez Oil spill, letting the oil giant off the hook on big damages. Thornburgh's fat pay as counsel to Kirkpatrick & Lockhart, the Washington law-and-lobbying outfit, is substantially due to his job as a Bush retainer. This is the kind of stinky conflict of interest that hardly suggests "independent." Why not just appoint Karl Rove as CBS' grand inquisitor and be done with it?

Then there's Boccardi, not exactly a prince of journalism. This is the gent who, as CEO of the Associated Press, spiked his own wire service's exposure of Oliver North and his traitorous dealings with the Ayatollah Khomeini. Legendary AP investigative reporters Robert Parry and Brian Barger found their stories outing the Iran-Contra scandal in 1986 stopped by their bosses. They did not know that Boccardi was on those very days deep in the midst of talks with North, participating in the conspiracy.

Today I spoke with Parry at his home in Virginia. He was sympathetic to Boccardi who at the time was trying to spring AP reporter Terry Anderson held hostage in Iran. But to do so, Boccardi joined, unwittingly, in a criminal conspiracy to trade guns for hostages. He then spiked his own news agency's investigation of it. Parry later discovered a 1986 email from North to John Poindexter in which North notes that Boccardi "is supportive of our terropism (sic) policy" and wants to keep the story "quiet." Poindexter was indicted, then pardoned. Boccardi was not, and there is no indication he knew he was abetting a crime. But the AP demoted journalist Barger and forced him to quit for -- the offense of trying to report the biggest story of the decade. This hardly gives Mr. Spike the qualification to pass judgment on working journalists.

And who are the journalists whom CBS has burned at the corporate stake? The first lined up for career execution is '60 Minutes' producer Mary Mapes. Besides the Bush draft dodge story, Mapes produced the exposé of the torture at Abu Ghraib when other networks had the same material and buried it.

I admit to a soft spot for Mapes. Four years ago, BBC Television London broadcast my report that Jeb Bush had wrongly purged thousands of African-Americans from the voter rolls, thereby fixing the election for his big brother. CBS Evening News ran away scared from the story, as did ABC and other US networks. This year, when Bush tried to repeat the trick, Mapes wanted to put it on '60 Minutes.' However, after the draft dodge story hullabaloo, that was not going to happen.

And what was the crime committed by Mapes and, let's not forget, Dan Rather, whose career was also toasted by the story?

CBS said, "The Panel found that Mapes ignored information that cast doubt on the story she had set out to report -- that President Bush had received special treatment 30 years ago, getting to the [Texas Air National] Guard ahead of many other applicants."

Well, excuse me, but that story is stone cold solid, irrefutable, backed-up, sourced, proven to a fare-thee-well. I know, because I'm one of the reporters who broke that story way back in 1999, for the Guardian papers of Britain. No one has challenged the Guardian report, or my follow-up for BBC Television, whatsoever, though we've begged the White House for a response from our self-proclaimed "war president."

CBS did not "break" this Chicken-Hawk George story; it's just that Dan Rather, with Mapes' encouragement, found his journalistic soul and the cojones, finally, after 5 years delay, to report it. Did Bush get special treatment to get into the Guard? Baby Bush tested in the 25th percentile out of 100. Yet, he leaped ahead of thousands of other Vietnam evaders because the then-Speaker of the Texas legislature sent a message to General Craig Rose, head of the Guard, to let in Little George and a few other sons of well-placed politicos.

[See some of the documentation here and a clip from the BBC Television report]

Mapes and Rather did make a mistake, citing a memo which could not be authenticated. But let's get serious folks: this "Killian" memo had not a darn thing to do with the story-in-chief -- the President's using his daddy's connections to duck out of Vietnam. The Killian memo was a goofy little addition to the story (not included in my Guardian or BBC reports).

So CBS inquisitors took this minor error and used it to discredit the story and ruin careers of reporters who allowed themselves an unguarded moment of courage. And, crucial to the network's real agenda, this nonsensical distraction allowed the White House to resurrect the fake reputation of George Bush as Vietnam-era top gun.

CBS executives' model was clearly the hatchet job done on BBC news last year by the so-called "Hutton Report." In that case, some used-up lordship viciously attacked the BBC's ballsy uncovering of an official lie: that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. Lord Hutton seized on a minor error by one reporter to attempt to discredit the entire BBC investigation of governmental mendacity.

In Britain, the public stood with the "Beeb." But in my own country, the American press itself, notably the New York Times, has joined in the lynch mob, repeating the allegations against the investigative reporters without any independent verification of the charges whatsoever.

I would note that neither CBS nor the New York Times punished a single reporter for passing on, as hard news, the Bush Administration fibs and whoppers about Saddam Hussein's nuclear and biological weapons programs. Shameful repetitions of propaganda produced no resignations -- indeed, picked up an Emmy or two.

Yes, I believe heads should roll at CBS: those of the "news" chieftains who for five years ignored the screaming evidence about George Bush's dodging the draft during the war in Vietnam.

At the top of the network's craven and dead wrong apology to the President is that cyclopsian CBS eyeball. But I suspect that CBS itself has little interest in eating its own flesh. This vile spike-after-broadcast serves only its master, the owner of CBS, Viacom Corporation.

"From a Viacom standpoint, the election of a Republican administration is a better deal. Because the Republican administration has stood for many things we believe in, deregulation and so on. I vote for Viacom. Viacom is my life, and I do believe that a Republican administration is better for media companies than a Democratic one."

That more-than-revealing statement, made weeks before the presidential election, by Sumner Redstone, billionaire honcho of CBS' parent company, wasn't reported on CBS. Why not? Someone should investigate.

Viacom needs the White House to bless its voracious and avaricious need to bust current ownership and trade rules to add to its global media monopoly. Placing the severed heads of reporters who would question the Bush mythology on the White House doorstep will certainly ease the way for Viacom's ambitions.

At the least, at the upcoming inaugural parties, CBS' ruler Redstone can expect that White House occupants will give him a standing Rove-ation.

---
Greg Palast's report for BBC Television on the President's evasion of the military draft can be seen in the BBC documentary, "Bush Family Fortunes," updated in a special US edition on DVD. See a segment here. Palast is the author of the New York Times bestseller, "The Best Democracy Money Can Buy." View his writings www.GregPalast.com For interviews, contact media(at)GregPalast.com

Saturday, January 15, 2005

PR Braindrain epilogue

Further to my PR Braindrain posting the other week, the UK edition of PR Week (January 14, 2005) ran a copy of my letter to the editor on the subject.

Badly run agencies will face brain drain

I was surprised to read some of the comments in a Financial Times article last week on an apparent brain drain of PR people from consultancy to in-house roles.

First, the assertion by the PRCA that this brain drain from the consultancies can be rectified by 'improving evaluation methods and developing industry-standar measures for PR effectiveness' is naive.

Having an industry that is more respected within businesses will benefit all PR professionals rather than just consultancies, and is likely to attract more competition for external PR from professional services firms such as management consultancies.

The migration to in-house roles happens for a number of reasons, including job security, finance, work-life balance, the working environment and a need for a different challenge.

Also the assertion that migration to in-house is 'driving everyone mad' by an anonymous PR consultancy spokesperson says more about their agency than the market for in-house PR people.

If an organistion is poorly managed then it will have staff-retention problems; it is of no surprise to me that it would wish to keep its company name out of the article

Ged Carroll - PR consultant
News in brief

Larry Ellison is cutting Peoplesoft jobs like Toshiro Mifune welding a katana in The Seven Samurai. A CBS Marketwatch bulletin just in put the number of employees picking up their P45s at 5,000, though the cuts will leave development and support staff largely unscathed.

The Harvard Crimson has an interview with Nick DePlume aka Nicholas Ciarelli, founder and writer of the ThinkSecret website. According to the article the core of Apple's legal beef with Ciarelli is that they complain Think Secret is illegally soliciting Apple employees to violate confidentiality agreements and disclosing that information online without Apple’s permission.

Offering tipsters anonymity, the website contact page urges visitors to submit insider gossip. Like most companies I've worked at, Apple uses confidentiality agreements to stop the disclosure of confidential information to anyone outside of the company. Apple claims that this has caused the company irreparable harm. Hmmm, what about the countless column inches, speculation, news analysis and debate that a technology company Apple's size would not usually merit? Secondly, these Apple employees if they are breaking the law, broke it of their own will.

You can read the article online here.
Big Mobile

At one time very long ago, Doctors could be seen on cigarette advertisements advocating the beneficial properties of menthol laced tabs. Viz magazine spoofed this and the 'Guinness is good for you' advertisements with their range of 'Ciggies and drink keep you in the pink' spoof ads and merchandise. Now we all know better, that in fact tabacco is the spawn of all evil, which is why chavs, students and attractive young women smoke.

Tabacco companies will soon be able to commiserate with mobile phone companies after the week that they've been having. First UK government experts from the National Radiological Protection Board say that mobile phones are bad for the health of children and more consideration should be given to siting of cellular base stations, now Securityfocus.org has a story written by Kevin Poulsen about the way a hacker cracked T-Mobile's network like an egg. In 30 years time we may have 'no phoning' policies and Nokiaette patches to help ease phoners away from their health destroying habit.

Friday, January 14, 2005

Krafty Kuts

Kraft Foods announced a welcome development. That it was looking to shift its advertising spend from directly targeting six-to-eleven year olds in pursuit of the 'nag factor' to sell products like Oreos and several child-orientated cereals. In addition, it was looking to roll out a flagging system to point out healthier items in their range.

The nag factor methodology of marketing to children in a cynical way was highlighted in The Corporation, a documentary about damaging behaviours of corporate organisations. You can see Kraft's press release here, Analysis from Netimperative about the impact to marketers here. Not-for-profit online outfit I Know is looking to highlight the impact of nag factor advertising when it is scheduled to launch next month.

Now all they need to do is completely revamp their Dairylea product range, strip ou the fat and put some nutritional value in there.
I know there's a great film in there somewhere

Oliver Stone's Alexander is not as bad as the critics say. Val Kilmer and Angelina Jolie both give sterling performances. Jolie as a parody of her kooky media persona and Kilmer as a twisted and tortured Dad to Colin Farrell. The cinematography is spectacular and the fight scenes are an equal to the opening scene of Gladiator.

Audiences may be confused by the way the plot twists backwards and forwards in time, narrated by Anthony Hopkins. The film alluded to the way the ancient world was governed by omens (looking at cattle entrails to figure out the future) and featured an eagle motif throughout the film. These devices whilst interesting to film studies students muddy the plot for Joe Sixpack, so do not expect Academy Awards. The Greeks were said to be offended for the implication in the film that Alexander is bisexual, actually the film shoves his bisexuality in your face. It is to Greek machismo what the more graphic scenes in Midnight Express were to Turkish masculinity.

Alexander's legacy has been cleansed and polished by time and Stone tried to make him human and put his successes and failures in perspective, the film feels that it has lost a bit of direction and some of the illustrative effects like maps on a rippling background and Alexander's delirium near death made it seem more like an acid trip. It will be interesting to see whether audiences grow more receptive to this film with time, I hope so as I believe that it has been unfairly written off by the critics.

Thursday, January 13, 2005

Real beauty - championed by a cosmetics company?

Dove's Campaign for Real Beauty is an interesting exercise on a number of levels. Whilst it is laudable that a stand has been taken against conventional beauty being the only measure for women, the campaign is flawed for a number of reasons.

First of all it is part of the cosmetics industry which has used advertising and point of purchase sale counters in department stores to point out to women how they can cover their unsightly features and given them unfair role models to aspire to. Hell, even catwalk models get the Photoshop treatment to enhance their skin for photo shoots. Dove owners Unilever should have started its campaign with a very public mea culpa for their past sins against women and alter its marketing of the Calvin Klein, Elizabeth Arden, Chloe, Faberge, Lagerfeld, Scherrer, Elizabeth Taylor and Valentino brands. Instead the research report carried out by a PR consultancy cops out and blames the media in general, please!


Secondly, plus-sized women, its not about how you feel about yourself - obesity is a health issue and predicted to be a future drain on healthcare resources dealing with diabetes, heart and circulatory issues and bone damage - the whole fat and proud thing doesn't wash. Heroin addict chic is not cool either.

Thirdly, the campaign doesn't seem to focus on the dynamics of beauty that much. An old girlfriend of mine once told me that women spruce themselves up to 'show out' and 'hold their own' against other women rather than to impress new or prospective partners. In addition, contrary to the implication of the adverts, many 'conventional' beauties are not appealing to men. Men actually have different tastes, so the notion of conventional beauty is tenuous. Note: all you Alex Kingston look-alikes can email me ;-)). I don't see any of this communicated in the messaging.

Finally if you are going to have an integrated marketing campaign, for pity's sake think the execution through. Guerilla activity on the London Underground posters for the Campaign for Real Beauty has shown at least some of the consumers disagree with Dove's concept of real beauty. Check out Spin Bunny's Mings of a Dove posting here and Dove's report developed by StrategyOne: a research company owned by global PR conglomerate Edelman here.
Crystal Ball Gazing

Over at PBS.org, Bob Cringely has put up his predictions for the technology industry this year. I have posted the highlights in italics and my comments below:

- Microsoft's entry into the anti-virus and anti-spyware businesses will be a disaster for users. This is based on everything I know about Microsoft, having watched the company for almost 28 years. They will make a big fanfare, spend a lot of marketing dollars, but in the end, the company simply won't be able to keep up with the demands of keeping virus signatures current, which isn't the real point of this gambit, anyway. There is so much to this story and so much that I could write that I think I'll do so next week, and just move on to the next prediction.

It reminded me of something an IRA spokesperson said after the RUC had prevented a bombing. We only have to be lucky once, you have to be lucky all the time. This is the situation that Microsoft has created for itself.. Whilst it looks to plug security holes, some of the worlds most talented code heads hunt for new ones to prove that it is nothing but a software collander.

- Carrying over from last year, I predict that Burst.com will beat Microsoft in their current lawsuit. But to avoid having to eat crow again over timing, let me put this in greater context. IF a trial actually takes place, as it is now scheduled to do this summer, Burst will easily win. Microsoft is at a disadvantage already as a bully. Burst will probably get Judge Motz to tell the jury that Microsoft deliberately destroyed evidence, and it doesn't hurt, either, that Burst is just plain right on all counts -- Microsoft DID violate their patents, DID violate Burst's non-disclosure agreement, DID attempt to illegally put them out of business, and DID attempt to control the market.

Of course, Microsoft might settle before trial, but at this point, I don't think that is likely out of simple arrogance on Microsoft's part. Microsoft is furious with Burst for the little company's continued survival, plus Microsoft is listening to the wrong lawyers on this one. So Burst will win on some or all counts ,and I expect the damage award to be in the billions. Of course, Microsoft will appeal. But the key difference between this case and other Microsoft cases is that once Burst wins, Real Networks and Apple Computer, both of which are also infringing Burst's patents (along with TiVO and a bunch of other companies), will immediately buy Burst licenses, throwing $100+ million into Burst's coffers and leading to everyone else EXCEPT Microsoft taking a Burst license, too. At that point -- if it goes that far and Microsoft is that stupid -- Redmond won't be able to risk not having a Burst license and will settle, too. Only by waiting so long Microsoft will have blown any number of advantages it could have had. Typical.

This is deja vu, Microsoft has a proven history of software piracy and IP theft. Stack software compression was one of the most high profile cases, it ran for years and by the time that the court had provided a remedy the damage had been done. I do not have the same faith in the process of law that Bob does.

- Apple will take a big risk in 2005. This could be in the form of a major acquisition. With almost $6 billion in cash, Steve Jobs hinted to a group of employees not long ago that he might want to buy something big, though I am at a loss right now for what that might be. Or Apple might decide to throw some of that cash into the box along with new computers by deliberately losing some money on each unit in order to buy market share.

We might see that as early as next week with the rumored introduction of an el-cheapo Mac without a display. The price for that box is supposed to be $499, which would give customers a box with processor, disk, memory, and OS into which you plug your current display, keyboard, and mouse. Given that this sounds a lot like AMD's new Personal Internet Communicator, which will sell for $185, there is probably plenty of profit left for Apple in a $499 price. But what if they priced it at $399 or even $349? Now make it $249, where I calculate they'd be losing $100 per unit. At $100 per unit, how many little Macs could they sell if Jobs is willing to spend $1 billion? TEN MILLION and Apple suddenly becomes the world's number one PC company. Think of it as a non-mobile iPod with computing capability. Think of the music sales it could spawn. Think of the iPod sales it would hurt (zero, because of the lack of mobility). Think of the more expensive Mac sales it would hurt (zero, because a Mac loyalist would only be interested in using this box as an EXTRA computer they would otherwise not have bought). Think of the extra application sales it would generate and especially the OS upgrade sales, which alone could pay back that $100. Think of the impact it would have on Windows sales (minus 10 million units). And if it doesn't work, Steve will still have $5 billion in cash with no measurable negative impact on the company. I think he'll do it.

Apple does need to take a risk, I am not sure that what Bob outlines is the risk. The reason why I think that Apple needs to take a risk is two-fold. Firstly, Apple survives and grows by being a hard target for the tech sector to catch: think the iMac or the iPod. Secondly, the Street now has a head of steam in a belief about sustainable growth at the company, this is not going to happen when the iPod looks as if it may have its marketshare hollowed out by the lemming-style approach of other PC manufacturers commoditising the market with inferior substitute products.

- The Recording Industries Association of America will continue to sue customers while their business slowly dissolves. The big threat here isn't file swapping, but affiliate programs like Apple's iTunes Affiliate Program that I am sure will be shortly copied by all the online music stores. These affiliate programs turn bloggers into shills and blogs into record stores, with the result that record company's last source of power -- marketing clout -- is taken away. This will take time, but it is the beginning of the end for old-style record companies.


- WiMax will be a huge story by summer, but widespread adoption of the wireless networking technology will take at least another two years. In the meantime, though, nobody will make money on WiFi, but it will become ubiquitous anyway, especially with the arrival of 802.11n.

WiMax has to go through all the stages on the Hurwitz hype curve yet

- VoIP will continue to shatter the telephone industry with the arrival of WiFi phones, which might finally be the killer app for hotspots. Eventually, all the backbone suppliers will figure out that VoIP is their salvation and will either start their own VoIP companies or ally with big VoIP players.

This is based on the assumption that the mobile phone companies are just going to sit there and take it like a bitch? Maybe in America.

- The trend of repurposing Linux-based consumer electronics devices through revised firmware will expand dramatically as people realize the cost-benefit advantage, AND nerds realize that they can sell reprogrammed WRT54GS stuff all over town and over the Internet. Just look at Sveasoft's James Ewing, sitting on a little island off the coast of Sweden serving firmware upgrades to 44,178 users who each put $20 per year into his PayPal account. Do the numbers. The next killer app in this space will be a cut-down version of the Asterisk Open Source PBX. Imagine a $100 box that manages your telco, VoIP, and mobile phone lines, making them appear as a virtual three-line phone with common dialing rules and always choosing the cheapest route for each call.

Hardware hacking does not need to happen just on Linux boxes, free software tools from chip manufacturers and cheap inventory / equipment on eBay will facilitate a hacker economy on a wide range of smart devices like the iPod.

- Desktop Linux will finally make some serious inroads as Linspire sets the trend for how to make Linux more user-friendly. There will undoubtedly be other players in this space, but they'll just be emulating Linspire (formerly Lindows). Now if Linspire could only manage a one-click installation of MythTV.

- And speaking of MythTV, 2005 will start to show some innovative online video initiatives. Don't expect this until late in the year, but the networks are starting to figure out that control of the broadcast schedule is being taken over by the viewers in a TiVO world, while producers with big libraries are starting to realize they don't need a network to sell bad TV. Since this is a tide they can't stop, the networks will have to decide how best they can surf it. Expect some interesting attempts this year, most of which will fail.

- In 2005, the major beneficiaries of the Peoplesoft-Oracle merger will be SAP and IBM, NOT Peoplesoft or Oracle customers, despite anything Larry Ellison says ("Oversupport" Peoplesoft customers? -- sheesh).

- Cisco will rediscover its ability to buy and assimilate startup companies since it REALLY needs a shot of new ideas and has a ton of cash to spend. At least, I hope they will.

- There is no evidence that Sun will change its current course, which is inexorably downward. I know Jonathan Schwartz thinks I'm crazy, but so far I am more right than he is, and hear no reason coming from him why that should change.

This is a real shame as Sun has been a force for good within the tech sector, from Java and Jini to providing a less vendor centric alternative to Microsoft Passport

- While Intel thinks its 2004 course corrections will do the job, I just don't see much in the new product roadmap to get excited about. AMD will continue to grow at Intel's expense. And keep an eye on IBM's PowerPC introductions later in the year that should really give Intel fits, especially if they are accompanied by substantial OEM agreements.

- Two thousand five will NOT be the year for UltraWide Band (UWB) networking or Power Line Networking, but both will do really well in 2006.

The dirty nature of electric power supplies in terms of mains spikes may see power line networks put off for years after 2006. Between research and hardware costs, it could be as cost effective to expand the DSL or cable modem network instead.

- Sony's PS3 will be delayed yet again, giving a real advantage to xBox2 IF Microsoft can get it out the door this year in volume.

Sony's wider strategy seems to be in some disarray, the universal media player properties of the PSP have not been all that well received thought it is a good mobile games machine by all accounts. The Connect music service has been slated and Sony is looking to throw its lot in with Microsoft according to some reports. Blu-Ray has a serious hurdle to adoption, because of the DVD patent pool tax and the declining margins in manufacturing DVD discs, Sony may be the only existing legal disc manufacturer who can afford to tool up for Blu-Ray. Most of the rest will look to use existing equipment to support HD-DVD instead.

Wednesday, January 12, 2005

Papas gotta brand new swag bag

Two recent stories caught my eye. Corporate sinners WorldCom and Enron have surfaced again with former board members agreeing to give back some of their loot. As part of a settlement of a class action suit against Enron former board members have agreed to hand over 13 million USD according to this report in the Washington Post.

In addition, ten former directors of WorldCom have agreed to pay 18 million USD between them as part of a court settlement. These agreements are highly unusual as directors legal costs and settlement payments are taken care of by the company or an insurer. Does this set a precedent against directors of other high profile business failures like Tyco Industries, the AOL Time-Warner merger, DrKoop.com or Boo.com?


Tuesday, January 11, 2005

MacWorld San Francisco

AppleInsider has a blow-by-blow account of Steve Jobs' keynote at MacWorld SF. The announcements did not contain too many surprises partly because of ThinkSecret and Apple's legal action against their site.

iPod Shuffle - this is Apple's attempt to enter the lower end of the MP3 player market, It is also more suitable for physical activity like jogging or the gym. It looks nice, if a bit Fisher-Price in its asthetic. I am particularly interested to see that it can be used as a flash drive for moving data around as well. The battery life is a surprisingly low 12 hours and it comes with a white lanyard, facilitating muggers who want to throttle their victim and steal their iPod.

Mac Mini - despite the hoopla this is an iBook specification PC for the home, it looks like a stack of large coffee coasters and allows existing PC users to through away their old beige box, keep the keyboard, mouse and screen and get something suitable for home computing and surfing the web without the bulk. It would be also ideal for thin client applications such as bank tellers, newspaper artworkers, retail situations and kiosks because of its size. For the price point users may also want to consider an eMac. I would not expect the Mac Mini to be upgradable in the future like a PC.

iWork - is the next generation AppleWorks (the child of Claris Works, the integrated spreadsheet, presentation and word processor that I used for my college course back-in-the-day). It comes with a new Word compatiable word-processing application and the latest iteration of Keynote. At 79 USD Stateside, it is worth it just for Keynote as its formatting capabilities eats PowerPoint for breakfast.

Christmas Reading & So Strange It Should be Fiction

Christmas Reading & So Strange It Should be Fiction

Cover art courtesy of Bloomsbury

In August I mentioned a New York Times review of the alleged next Harry Potter book. Whilst waiting at London City Airport on Christmas Eve to fly home to my family I managed to pick up a soft back copy of Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clark which apparently is an 'airport exclusive'. Like the Potter series, this fantasy novel is published by Bloomsbury and they have a successful product on their hands. However the products are poles apart, Clark's work reminds me of the intellectual rigour that you find in the Lord of the Rings as Tolkein's background in old English literature shows through. Clarks efforts are based on gaelic faerie tales, the Brothers Grimm, Napoleonic history, the gentlemen of Dickensian and Kipling literature and a love of the English language. Antique English is given a salute with show and showed being substituted with shew and shewed respectively.

It is not a book for the faint-hearted weighing at almost 800 pages, so do not expect readers to come from Harry Potter's younger audience but his adult fans, they may be joined by graphic novel fans who would appreciate its richness and depth. I think it is one of the cleverest novels since Alan Moore's The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen volume one and it has praise on the back cover by Neil Gaiman, better known as the author behind the Sandman series. It is interesting that Susanna Clarke cites Alan Moore's earlier Watchmen graphic novel as an influence

The second book that I read was The Forty Seven Ronin Story by John Allyn. This is based on one samurai honor and bravery. In 1702, Naganori Asano-Takuminokami was on a ceremonial visit to the Shogun, he was insulted by a greedy and corrupt courtier, Lord Asano struck the courtier with his sword, violating the law, and resulting in his own order to commit ceremonial
suicide. His estates became forfeit to the Shogunate and all of his retained samurai became ronin.

They plotted revenge and regaining their honour by killing the courtier, 47 of the ronin bided their time, and struck back. Though their devotion to Bushido impressed the entire nation, the Shogun had no choice by to give them the most lenient sentence that he could - committing ceremonial suicide.

It is a fantastic book with real depth and contextualises the culture for a gaijin such as myself.

The Smoking Gun has alleged summary of evidence on what has been uncovered in the Michael Jackson case here and it makes for disturbing reading that is also strangely compelling, see for yourself here. By their own admission this report is based on the review of documentation provided by sources who allegedly had access to secretl police and government reports, grand jury testimony, and sealed court records. It may be true,or The Smoking Gun may have been hoaxed.

Monday, January 10, 2005

Phuctcompany.com

Thanks to the Global Telecoms Business top five stories daily newsletter for highlighting this interesting memo from Equant, the majority owned international arm of France Telecom. Apparently Equant has a high burn rate, has made significant losses and lost almost half its market capitalisation.

Reminds me of the telecoms bust of 2000/2001 with Exodus, WorldCom, PSINet, RSL COM and Global Crossing. Paul Durman of the Sunday Times wrote an interesting comment piece about the memo Happy New Year from the boss - you're about to get fired.

You can subscribe to the GTB email newsletter by emailing Alan Burkitt-Gray. Tell'em the renaissance chambara blog sent you
Next year's colour for living rooms? Lemon

Thanks to VNU for their Consumer Electronics Show coverage blog we have a blow by blow account of Bill Gates' presentation on the living room of the future. Like a dysfunctional family there were the inevitable breakdowns in communication (between the PC and a Nikon camera), relationships got a little icy (when an XBox froze into the blue screen of death) and some family members decide not to turn up at all (like the MSN Remote service when the onstage internet connection failed and they could not show how a Microsoft PC can be controlled remotely to record a TV programme).

With great marketing chutzpah Microsoft hid these inevitable faults by having the the presentation co-hosted by Conan O'Brien - heir apparent to the Late Show mantle. Microsoft is used to having product failures mar marketing exercises at events such as Comdex, so was well prepared with a metaphoric roll of wallpaper and bucket of paste. It would be a mistake to think from these errors that the company is not serious about invading the living room, be afraid.

Sunday, January 09, 2005

Daggers Drawn

Daggers Drawn

I managed to get to see one of the most eagerly awaited Chinese films of 2004 with my friend Steve; House of Flying Daggers. The film was a mix of wirework acrobatics, martial arts skill and Western style computer graphics. The plot nipped along at a rate of knots until the final fight setpiece when the heroine came back more times from the dead than Lazarus and Jesus combined; a truly operatic scene.

Unexpectedly for a martial arts film it has enough romantic bits in it you can bring her indoors along to watch it with you. An entertaining film, but does not compare to the Jet Li film Hero made around the same time.

Saturday, January 08, 2005

24 Season Four

I found a great website that is hosting all the US TV teasers for the return of Jack Bauer and company. 24 returns to US television screens on January 9th. So far, the websites that have reviews of the first few episodes point out the dislocation they felt from having so many new faces onboard.

TVRules.net provides a synopsis to the start of the series here.

FOX’s award-winning dramatic series "24" returns for it's fourth season of clock-stopping suspense beginning with an explosive season premiere of two back-to-back episodes airing Sunday, January 9, 2005 (8:00-10:00 PM). The series will then move into it's new timeslot Monday nights at 9:00 PM beginning Monday, January 10.

In season three of 24, Jack, who was in charge of a special field operations unit of the Counter Terrorist Unit, fought to stop a viral terrorism threat before it could kill millions of people.

Season four begins 18 months later with the episode “Day 4: 7:00 am – 8:00 am.” CTU is now headed by Erin Driscoll (Alberta Watson, “La Femme Nikita”), a steely government agent who made firing Jack one of her first priorities upon taking over.

After the explosion of a commuter train, Jack, who is now working for Secretary of Defense James Heller (William Devane, “Knots Landing”) and also is romantically involved with his married daughter, Audrey (Kim Raver, “Third Watch”), suddenly finds himself heading back to CTU for a meeting with Driscoll on Heller’s behalf.

Also featured will be Nestor Serrano (“The Day After Tomorrow”) as Middle Eastern businessman Navi Araz, Oscar-nominated actress Shohreh Aghdashloo (“The House of Sand and Fog”) as his wife, Dina, and Jonathan Ahdout (“The House of Sand and Fog”) as their son, Behrooz.

Friday, January 07, 2005

Quicktime Short

Not as one would expect, Rebecca Loos pleasuring farm animals, Farm Sluts takes its name from the vilest of spam emails that often end up in your work email account. Here is a great 17-minute comedy short from American TV channel Fox Searchlight. Quicktime is required for viewing (at 49MB its not dial-up friendly, you've been warned).

Thursday, January 06, 2005

Power Pizzas

Power Pizzas

One of my colleagues Dave used to say that the security experts at his former employer advocated carrying a laptop outside in a sturdy carrier bag rather than the dull holdalls that come free with Dell laptops as these gave a subliminal message to career criminals, drug fiends and listless teenagers that said 'Take me please, I'm all yours'. So they would approved of Humanbeans 'Power Pizza' box, a pizza box with foam and securing straps to securely hold your prized PowerBook.

There is also a certain symmetry as pizza boxes are often left lying around as IT people solve network problems and do all-night coding sessions fueled on slabs of pizza and the most highly caffeinated beverages of their preference.


Disorganised Organisations

Demos the think-tank beloved of new Labour issued a report in November last year that slipped under the radar until now. Disorganisation: Why organisations should loosen up collated a lot of useful information about the trend towards teleworking and the subversion of rigidity in traditional company cultures. Whilst you could argue that the involvement of Orange as a PR exercise in developing the report tainted its conclusions the collection of case studies and research are very useful for justifying the Treo 650 you bought on the company credit card last month. Available here as a PDF (warning its 69 pages long).

Demos also has a useful page of links here.

Wednesday, January 05, 2005

Winter Wonderland

The San Jose Mercury News has a great preview article covering the Consumer Electronics Show which starts tomorrow in Las Vegas. Apparently Bill Gates is doing a keynote to try and justify the existence of a monopolistic software company in a wireless living room through Microsoft Windows*, a similar song-and-dance routine is expected on the following two days by Carly Forina and Craig Barrett - yawn, why not just get Michael Jackson or Siegfried and Roy instead? *Microsoft Windows is a trademark of Microsoft Corporation (and they are welcome to it!). According to the article the big themes this year in new products are:

  • Portable devices: Sony's tombstone like PSP portable games and media console gets its US launch, portable DVD and video players, satellite radios
  • Cell phones featuring WiFi internet access
  • WiFi and Bluetooth connectivity for televisions and other home entertainment equipment in place of reliable and inexpensive cabling
  • HD-DVD versus Blu-Ray: battle of the future DVD standards for even more commentaries and subtitle languages
  • iPod accessories: no sh!t Sherlock?
  • Bigger flatter TVs: CRT - RIP maybe
Do you spell Vietnam I-R-A-Q?

An interesting insight from Iraq via an anonymous informant for the Investors Insight /What We Now Know email newsletter. The cynical could draw parallels between the South Vietnamese Forces versus the Hill Tribes and the Iraqis versus the Kurd comparisons.

MR. X: BACK IN IRAQ

Our anonymous "on-the-ground" informant, Mr. X, is back. After his last assignment as a bodyguard for executives of a reconstruction company in Baghdad ended, we weren't sure we'd ever hear from him again. But here he is, back in the trenches, with more of his unique insider views...

Just six weeks ago I was sitting on a beach in Waikiki enjoying my hard-earned money when I got the inevitable email. "Hey man, you gotta come back over here. I have a skate (easy) job for you. And you won't believe the pay!...."

And as much as I hoped I would never set foot in the Middle East again for as long as I lived, the pay was just too much to pass up. But this time I didn't come over for PSD (bodyguard) work. This contract was just a training mission. It was to train Kurdish Peshmerga and Iraqi recruits in Mosul on force protection/base defense operations. It should have been an easy 90-day contract....

I lasted two weeks.

It was without a doubt the most frustrating experience of my life. The Iraqi recruits were the biggest "oxygen thieves" I've ever seen (an old military term). In the first class we had (their training course lasts 2 weeks), we didn't graduate even one worthwhile troop. Not one.

It was obvious the Iraqi recruits didn't care about their jobs. They just joined to collect the paycheck and hope that the insurgents wouldn't hit them. I guess it's no surprise every time Iraqi forces have been attacked, they either ran or surrendered.

Although I was hoping it was just one bad class and maybe the next one would be different, the other instructors assured me that was a typical class of recruits. But they didn't care. They just went through the motions of training them and collected their paychecks from the U.S. government.

But for me, the frustration was just too much. I packed up my stuff, made some phone calls and caught the next helo to Baghdad. Then I took a job doing bodyguard work again. Since I'm already over here, I might as well work a couple months, make a little cash and make the whole experience worth my time, at least financially.

The funny thing was that as worthless as the Iraqis were who we trained, the Kurds were the complete opposite. They were great guys with great attitudes, hard-working, trustworthy. I could go on and on. I only wish it were possible to let the Kurds guard the whole country! It sort of reminded me of how the Ghurkas have been for the British forces. I believe the Kurds have the potential to be the same for the U.S.

Of course, I realize the importance of trying to get the Iraqi military and police forces spun-up and operational. And with the upcoming election, that need is greater than ever. But until Iraqi men actually care enough about the security of their own country enough to be willing to fight for it, I just can't see much progress happening in the future. And just because there are lines around the corner at every police and military recruiting center, that doesn't mean that those recruits are actually willing to serve and make sacrifices for their country.

And on a side note, we're not really surprised about Mosul heating up. All the intel pointed to an operational shift in the insurgency once the Marines went into Fallujah in November. We expected them to relocate and regroup. Obviously, one of the places they chose was the Mosul/Tal Afar area. Surprisingly, Baghdad has been pretty quiet as far as the number of attacks on coalition forces recently.

I'll let you know if I see anything interesting or maybe newsworthy over here. Although I'm hoping for a quiet couple of months. Take care.

Tuesday, January 04, 2005

PR Braindrain

The FT has an interesting article on the drain of agency PR talent inhouse. Quite bizarrely the PRCA claims that the solution is making PR more measurable and enhancing the view of PR as a profession. Respect will benefit in-house practitioners and attract new competition from management consultants for PR agencies. The real issue is that PR consultants are moving agency side when it is more lucrative and less work. Agencies can expect to lose staff, particularly those that have had:
  • Pay freezes on for the past three years
  • Not recognised talent within their own ranks
  • Have had political games played out
  • Have had a rotating door of senior management
The clients get creative
By Meg Carter

Microsoft, PepsiCo, Woolworths and Accenture are among a growing list of brand owners to have poached public relations consultancy staff to fill their own in-house PR jobs in recent months. While the flow of PRs between consultancy and client and vice versa is nothing new, both head-hunters and consultancy bosses claim current levels of client poaching pose a major challenge for the industry.

"It's driving everyone mad," one senior PR consultancy executive complains. "It's happened to us three times in the past 12 months and we ended up losing business as a result. There's a real shortage of creative talent on the client side, in my view, and the way this is being dealt with is unacceptable."

Facing financial and time pressures and a need for direct experience of the brand among PR candidates, many clients are under pressure to poach. "It's a growing trend, and it can save a client huge amounts of time and money - get the right person and they'll hit the ground running without any need for induction," says Melanie Lawn, a recruitment consultant at Blue Skies Specialist Recruitment.

Consultancy PRs are only too willing to jump ship, it seems, as they grow increasingly frustrated by long working hours, woolly career prospects and lack of respect. According to a new survey of PR consultancy staff conducted by the Public Relations Consultants Association, a UK industry body, long working hours, salary levels below client rates and unclear career paths are the main reasons for considering a client PR role.

Historically, worsening economic conditions have encouraged clients to rely on in-house PR resources. In boom times they invest more on external PR support, says Patrick Barrow, PRCA director general and former head of external communications for T-Mobile, the mobile phone operator.

"Tough economic conditions have always been a challenge for the PR industry," he explains. "But despite 2004 being a better year for the PR business, there's a widespread feeling the pendulum is yet to swing back in PR consultancies' favour."

The PRCA survey, which polled PR company staff at the junior account executive level and more senior account and associate director level, shows relief from excessively long hours is one of the main reasons for considering a client PR role. "Career prospects are limited if you work a five day week," was one respondent's observation.

"A number of PR sectors are female-dominated and this is another factor. When people return to work after having children, many opt for in-house roles in the belief that support will be greater, pressure less and working hours shorter," Mr Barrow explains.

Lack of money is especially pressing for younger PRs a few years into their careers. Many are still struggling to pay off student debt, he says. Just as significant, however, is lack of respect. "Clients treat you like a skivvy, not a consultant," said one respondent.

Mr Barrow says he was surprised at the degree of discontent among PR consultants. However, there is no shortage of other industry figures willing to endorse the survey's finding and suggest supplementary factors.

"It's a fact that the advance from account executive to account director within a PR consultancy happens relatively quickly, while the next step - from account director to board director - can take 10 years," says Robert Phillips, co-founder of JCPR, a consumer PR consultancy. "People's careers therefore naturally plateau around 30."

Adds Niamh Byrne, director of PR at Orange: "I've noticed people are applying a lot more from agencies to come in-house in search of greater focus. They yearn to work on one brand and be able to follow a project through instead of constantly having to chop and change. And they relish the focus we place on coming up with our own creative ideas in-house."

One solution to the talent drain away from PR consultancies, the PRCA believes, lies in improving evaluation methods and developing industry-standard measures for public relations effectiveness - something the PRCA is backing. "Better demonstrate how PR impacts on the bottom line and PR's professional status can be strengthened and PR consultants enjoy greater respect," Mr Barrow says.

Mr Phillips agrees. "Accountability is key. Chief executives don't buy into emotions - they want to know how every investment impacts on the bottom line. PR must re-position itself as a strategic marketing discipline rather than a series of tactics thrown together," he says.

PR consultancy bosses privately admit much still needs to be done to banish once and for all negative associations with Absolutely Fabulous, the British sitcom, fluffy consumer surveys and the dark arts of spin doctoring. In the face of cost-cutting and the desire of clients like Orange to "own" creative thinking in-house, however, reversing the PR talent drain may prove to be an uphill struggle.

WHAT MAKES A GOOD IN-HOUSE PR

* MICROSOFT Microsoft UK took on three new in-house public relations people in 2004 - two from PR companies, the third from another IT-related company's PR department. Microsoft works with 60 or 70 external PR people in four companies who spend 50 to 60 per cent of their time on the brand. When recruiting to fill in-house PR positions Hugh Davies, Microsoft UK group PR manager, says how well an applicant "aligns with the company's brand values" is as important as their core experience and qualifications. "Increasingly, we're expected to employ people able to be trusted advisers, which means we are looking for people able to be proactive, used to selling in ideas, and adept at negotiating a complex web of different stakeholders," he says. "An agency background can therefore be useful although, of course, we must not hire away from the agencies working for us for contractual reasons."

* ORANGE Orange actively recruits PR staff for its in-house media centre with a mix of experience, drawing from other client companies' in-house PR departments, PR companies and journalists. "We're looking for people who'll fit with the Orange environment which is very fast-moving and lifestyle-focused," says Niamh Byrne, Orange's director of PR. Orange employs nine in-house PR people and also works with Cake and Edelman for support in consumer and business PR respectively. A key strength of PR company recruits is their familiarity with dealing daily with journalists, she adds: "We want to recreate that daily dialogue between Orange and the media in-house all the time to double the effort."
Volksmac

When Hitler got Dr Porsche to design the Volkswagen in the 1930's, he had a vision of Germans free to drive the length and breadth of the Fatherland on autobahns. Rumour sites including Think Secret and newspaper Apple watchers are speculating on an uber-cheap 'peoples' Mac to follow the iPod into Windows homes. Charles Arthur's piece in The Independent (UK) that looks to be based on ThinkSecret is here, ThinkSecret's speculation is here and Charles' related blog entry is here.

I am inclined to be skeptical about this, since it goes against Apple's strengths at the present time, their computers typically enjoy a 25 - 30 per cent margin, but then iTunes Music Service is a volume rather than margin business. If it does go pear-shaped it would be a far more high profile failure than the Apple Cube.
The eBay Economy

Much has been made of the eBay, the way it has transformed garage sales, small businesses and not so small businesses. It approximates a perfect market more closely than comparision shopping engines like Dealtime, MySimon or Froogle. My clients have been found online at thte weekend checking the current bid price on old car speakers they sold via eBay and a friend in the Philippines has a small business selling vintage watches to collectors worldwide. eBay's laissez-faire attitude to allow self policing of its communities via recommendations has made has been a blessing and curse. eBay has become a lightning rod for issues involving grassroots merchantism over the web, he brand has to constantly fight against perceptions of fraud, misselling and piracy.

eBay has successfully fought off or purchased a succession of competitors, who in the UK now remembers brands like QXL? One less remarked on winner in the eBay economy is Amazon. Its zShops and Marketplace allows small businesses and consumers to reach customers via one of the most highly visited properties on the web. In addition, Amazon has a win-win approach on the transaction. If consumers buy off Amazon its a traditional sale, the company makes it margin, if the consumer purchases a good from Marketplace or zShops Amazon takes its cut on the transaction. This is the eBay model by stealth, so far having shopped using Marketplace and zShops for the best part of 18 months I have had no complaints and have been able to obtain out-of-print books such as Moshe Dayan's autobiography.

With this in mind I was surprised to read this criticism of Amazon moving beyond books in Frank Barnako's Internet Daily email newsletter for CBS Marketwatch below. For the record, I would contend that most of the 3 billiion or so accumulated losses were made when Amazon subsidised books and delivery to create an online market in the first place and on expensive brand building advertising campaigns.

The author or co-author of 11 books about branding and marketing thinks the man behind Amazon.com (AMZN) does not deserve the kudos of Business Week magazine. Al Ries said Jeff Bezos should not be touted as one of the greatest innovators of the past 75 years because ... Amazon.com doesn't make money. Writing on AdAge.com, Ries says at the rate Amazon.com is going it will take the online retailer 85 years to break even from its accumulated $3 billion in losses. "Amazon.com pioneered a number of Internet innovations like one-click shopping," Ries concedes.

But "Bezos went off the track" by adding dozens of other product categories to the business." Bezos should emulate Nintendo (NTDOY), Ries said. "If you want to make money, keep your brand focused. If you want to make the pages of Business Week, be our guest and get into everything."

Monday, January 03, 2005

Are US brands taking an asswhooping from American foreign policy?

This should have been the title for an article that appeared in the Financial Times over the Christmas period called Tarnished Image: is the world falling out of love with US brands (paid subscription required).

The article does not reach a conclusion that this is the case, despite a call to boycott by many in the Middle East and apparent declines in Old Europe by standard bearers such as McDonalds. The academic research carried out measuring the the effect on brands has been inconclusive and as the author points out, it would be hard to separate the effects of hostility to American foreign policy from anti-globalisation and the rise of challenger brands from other countries.

A box-out in the article points out the potential threat from Japan taking over as the leader of global cool. This has already happened:

  • Sainsburys and Tesco now sell bento box style lunch packs to office workers
  • Fashionable graphic designers such as Designers Republic owe more than a little of their 'look' to Japanese packaging design
  • In film Kurosawa is cited by many directors from Sergio Leone on as an important influence
  • The Kill Bill duology is a homage to Chinese and Japanese action movies
  • Evisu the Japanese jeans brand leads the likes of Diesel and Levis in design and is one of the most frequently copied and faked apparel fashion brands
  • SHISEIDO cosmetics are at the bleeding edge of beauty products for women
  • Manga is influencing everyday art from Britney Spears videos to Western comics
  • The sublime global dominance of Hello Kitty
  • The success of sites such as oki-ni.com and J-List.com

'Cool would come from Tokyo rather than LA'

US brands face a new threat in Asia. But it has less to do with the policies of President George W.Bush than with the preferences of consumers such as Han Yue, a 21-year-old native of Shenyang, China, who has moved to Singapore to learn about the property business.

Shopping on Singapore's bustling Orchard Road, Ms Han makes clear that she looks to other Asian countries for her cultural cues. She is not hostile to US brands: some even strike her as "sexy". She just prefers fashions from Japan. "I think they are very cute," she says. "They look very young."

Ms Han's cultural sensibility is important. Marketing services executives see little evidence that the war in Iraq is provoking an overt backlash among Asian consumers. But they do see signs that some consumers are increasingly indifferent to US brands and are paying great attention to Asian trends and products.

"Japan is really what people are looking at for quality and relevance," says Andy Wilson, regional planning director in Asia-Pacific for the Ogilvy & Mather advertising agency. "Cool would definitely come from Tokyo rather than Los Angeles."

The growing interest in Asian labels is a challenge for US brands, but not an insurmountable one. Across the street from Ms Han, a sign in the window of a Levi's store on Orchard Road proclaims that "iconic American jeanswear" can be found inside. If the image of the US has been tarnished, there is no sign of it on the rear ends of Singaporeans. Levi's commands 85 per cent of the country's premium jeans market, says Charles Wigley, strategic planning director for the BBH advertising agency in Asia.

Mr Wigley says that kind of market dominance is difficult in the west, where young trendsetters often abandon products because they are popular. By contrast, consumers in Asia still see brands as guarantors of reliability. "There is still a good deal of comfort and attraction in brands in Asia," says Linda Locke, regional creative director for the Leo Burnett advertising agency.

Also, US brands have done an artful job of blurring their ties to their home market. Last year, a survey by Leo Burnett in China, India, Korea, Indonesia and the Philippines found that 49 per cent of respondents saw Coca-Cola as a global brand. Only 31 per cent viewed it as American and 15 per cent considered it to be local.

Since the Iraq war, Ms Locke says, US brands have been trying to stress their ties to local producers and franchise owners. For example, McDonald's has been running advertisements celebrating the lives of people in Indonesia, the world's largest Muslim country.

Maurice Levy, chief executive of Publicis, the marketing services group, says he has yet to see "an important sign" that the Iraq war is seriously harming western brands in Asia. "It is more a subject of debate between intellectuals than something that is hampering the development of these brands with consumers," he says.

The danger for US companies is that they will fail to appreciate the growing self-assurance of consumers in markets such as China or India. This increasing confidence could translate into a growing tendency to take offence at cultural slights.

This month, China banned a Nike advertisement that depicted US basketball star, LeBron James, defeating a kung fu master and other Chinese cultural icons in a video game-style battle.

China said the advertisement was offensive. Advertising executives suggested Nike erred by not letting the home side win. BBH got a better response with a Levi's advertisement that showed an Asian man facing down a street full of mean-looking westerners. "We have to be very careful about advertising in these countries," Mr Levy said. "We know cultural things are very touchy."

Sunday, January 02, 2005

Supersize me

Whilst it is obvious that Supersize Me had an agenda and I was particularly sympathetic to its point about the ways in which the food industry markets to children. I still find it hard to dislike McDonalds despite their low wages and the slightly sinister nature of Ronald McDonald because they once employed me for six weeks, at a time when the only growth industry in Merseyside was sham training companies set up on the back of government 'back to work' initatives.

Supersize Me had some interesting data:

  • Many filling stations sell more sweets and soft drinks than petrol and diesel
  • There are over three million food and drink vending machines in the US
  • Two out of every three American adults are obese
  • Over a third of American children are overweight
  • The Island of Manhattan has the highest density of McDonald's restaurants in the world
  • Eating chocolate affects the same receptors in the human brain as heroin